What shall we do about supposed anti-English sentiment among Scots?

John Major is on record as accusing Scottish nationalists of exploiting anti-English sentiment for their own political ends and of trying to deliberately “irritate and enrage”.  Andrew Marr said recently that “there is a very strong anti-English feeling” in Scotland.  Willie Rennie, the leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats, has pointed to an undercurrent of anti-English sentiment in Scotland.  Scottish commentators have complained recently that London-based journalists are sniffing around for expressions of anti-English sentiment while covering the Commonwealth Games.   

For me, there is enough anecdotal evidence from both Scots and English to give consideration to the issue of anti-English sentiment, but in two different contexts.  My preferred context for discussion of the issue is some time after the referendum when the political temperature has dropped.   Then, we will be in a better position to examine the roots of any such sentiment at leisure.  At the same time, an English / Scottish dialogue could look at the corresponding issue of anti-Scottish sentiment in England, for which I believe there is also enough anecdotal evidence to justify further study.   There is every reason to have this discussion in order to improve bilateral relations, especially as our relations look set to change whatever the outcome of the referendum.  

The other context for discussion of alleged anti-English sentiment is the present one i.e. in the middle of the independence referendum campaign.  I will focus on this here.  The danger is that this issue can turn into a political football which cheapens the whole debate and damages relations between England and Scotland. 

To investigate the issue more deeply, I suggest that we test the following hypothesis:

“Anti-English sentiment in Scotland is now sufficiently serious to be a significant factor in voting intentions in the referendum”.

As with every hypothesis, we need to look for evidence to support or refute it and also the quality of that evidence.  The evidence on such a touchy-feely issue will mainly amount to the positions of the major players in the referendum debate, the facts as to whether their actions are consistent with their opinions, and anecdotal experience from a fair cross-section of the electorate. 

On the “No” side, the UK Government has made no formal allegation of anti-English sentiment.  The Better Together campaign alleges that the policies of the Scottish Government erect unnecessary barriers against the English and this indirectly stokes anti-English sentiment.  But they don’t allege any campaign from the “Yes” side to generate anti-English sentiment.

On the “Yes” side, the Scottish Government and Yes Scotland makes a political case for rejection of the current Westminster political system, rejection of the policies of recent and present Conservative governments, and the re-balancing of the British economy to reduce dominance by London and the South-East of England.  They do not make this case by using any language suggestive of anti-English sentiment. 

From my limited experience of the blogosphere, arguments rage mainly between Scottish nationalists and unionists and less so between Scots and English.  Opinions expressed are largely consistent with the official campaign positions I have mentioned above.  On occasion, a nationalist makes a crude comment to the effect that the Scots are better off without the English but other nationalists challenge and moderate those comments.   Supporters of independence are often scrupulous in distinguishing their political differences with Westminster and English Conservative policies from their feelings about English people.  I have not seen any forum where anti-English sentiment is the orthodox position. 

So if my analysis holds true, there is no significant evidence that whatever anti-English sentiment that might exist is a significant factor in referendum voting intentions. If I am right, this calls into question why some English and Scottish politicians and broadcasters would raise anti-English sentiment as an issue during the campaign. There are several possible reasons:

1)      At worst, it is a pure smear tactic to scare voters towards a “No” vote.  Obviously, this would be reprehensible and I hope it is not true.

2)      They may genuinely believe that there is strong and persuasive expression of anti-English sentiment in the debate but they have not tested their own opinions against the facts.  As professionals in their fields, they have a duty to do their research before speaking out.  Not to do so is just laziness.

3)      They may genuinely believe that there is a deeper undercurrent of anti-English sentiment which is never made public, but have no evidence to support their position.  If they speak out on this basis, they are just casting aspersions and poisoning relations between us. 

4)      They may have actual evidence of a deep and wide undercurrent of anti-English sentiment which Scots never express publicly.  If they do, they need to be very respectful as to how and when they broadcast this and also examine their own motivations for doing so during the referendum campaign.  Anything short of this would also poison the debate.

The reasons for strong anti-English feeling (if it exists) would, in my view, be better explored outside an election campaign.  If Scots really don’t like us so deeply, they are entitled to their feelings – there is probably something behind them.  But we shouldn’t try to expose them or embarrass them into changing their views about us, especially during a political campaign about their future.  The best we can expect is that they speak respectfully to us and about us.  And they have the right to demand the same from us. 

So English politicians and broadcasters need to be aware of their own roles as ambassadors for England when they venture into Scottish politics and discuss Scottish national feelings.  If they idly accuse Yes-voting Scots of being anti-English, then they can expect them to be upset.  If they then translate this upset into evidence of anti-English sentiment, then their own actions are fulfilling their own prophecies.  In so doing, they are poisoning relations between the peoples of England and Scotland and engaging in gutter politics. They should ask themselves if in fact they are anti-Scottish.




8 thoughts on “What shall we do about supposed anti-English sentiment among Scots?

  1. I have no feelings towards the English or England.This isn’t indifference,ignorance or any other knee jerk thoughts those of you with pre-conceived ideas about us may have.
    It is just,for me,that you are a foreign country.Much the same as France or Spain.
    I harbour no ill-will to these countries and enjoy my visits,as I do to England.It doesn’t mean that I must formulate an opinion on an entire population,good or bad.
    I do find however,that many people have views on Scotland and the wider world in general.These people are nationalists.Their views are dividing and insular.I’m not saying that these views don’t exist in Scotland.They do,it’s just that they’re usually wrapped up in the union flag.
    If we are to examine our feelings towards other countries and peoples,we must first examine the views we hold of our own.A quandary which will hopefully be rectified when the YES vote is returned.

  2. Thanks for your comment, Goldenayr. I agree with you on everything you say and especially about having a conversation first of all within one’s own nation about what we think of ourselves. I am trying to do this in England with my other blog – englishnationalconversation.wordpress,.com It hasn’t taken off and I don’t know if it ever will. I wouldn’t mind if such a conversation was taking place elsewhere, but so far, I haven’t found it.

    • The conversations happening,it’s just not visible.

      Look at the grassroots movement in the YES campaign.These are people who don’t normally engage with politics.
      I have a suggestion,why not hand out yes badges and wristbands to your friends.It works here,where everyone knows what they are,in starting a conversation.
      It might engage them where you are as well.

      You never know,you might start a fashion.

  3. That’s an interesting idea. I had thought of a different marketing idea – badges or stickers containing the individual flags of Wales, Scotland and England then with a Union Jack with a big cross through it. Beneath each flag you could have a comment “Yes to Wales, Yes to Scotland, Yes to England, No to Great Britain”. (I’ll leave N Ireland out of it.) What do you think?

  4. First thoughts…there would be a knee jerk reaction from those who don’t understand the context.Also,any marketing tool has to have an immediate impact.The YES paraphernalia can be utilised to mean anything.Someone in London,upon seeing a YES badge,might not know what it relates to.You can then explain that you’re showing solidarity with their cause and you want to start a debate about England’s place in the world.
    Doors open when peoples interest is piqued.

  5. Thanks for your thoughts. I’ve been driving around with a Yes Scotland car sticker for a while now in the English Midlands but it’s not yet produced a conversation. More worried about a smashed window! I’ve got a friend to come up with an image for the other car sticker I mentioned already. So I’ll put it out there soon for comment.

  6. hello there and thank you for your information – I have
    definitely picked up anything new from right here.
    I did however expertise a few technical points using this site,
    as I experienced to reload the site lots of times previous
    to I could get it to load properly. I had been wondering if your hosting is OK?
    Not that I am complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will sometimes affect your placement
    in google and could damage your quality score if advertising and marketing
    with Adwords. Well I’m adding this RSS to my e-mail and can look out for much more of
    your respective fascinating content. Ensure that you update this
    again very soon.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s